Fedora Desktop on XO
erik at laptop.org
Tue Jan 6 13:52:06 EST 2009
On Tue, Jan 06, 2009 at 01:31:12PM -0500, Chris Ball wrote:
> Hi Peter,
> > How did you go with this? Did you have any luck? I also realised
> > that if you drop gnome-user-share you'll drop all the httpd
> > requirements.
> Yep, it worked! I had RPM conflicts in GConf2 (against GConf2-dbus,
> both ship the same .mo files) and evince (against sugar-evince, both
> ship the same evince backend shared libraries). Also, it turns out
> that evince-dvi is responsible for bringing in texlive, via kpathsea.
> Here's the command I'm using now:
> -bash-3.2# yum -y install NetworkManager-gnome alacarte at-spi bug-buddy
> control-center eog file-roller gcalctool gdm gdm-user-switch-applet
> gedit gnome-applets gnome-audio gnome-backgrounds gnome-media
> gnome-panel gnome-power-manager gnome-screensaver gnome-session
> gnome-system-monitor gnome-terminal gnome-user-docs gnome-utils
> gok gthumb gucharmap gvfs-archive gvfs-fuse gvfs-gphoto2 gvfs-smb
> libcanberra-gtk2 metacity mousetweaks nautilus orca
> pulseaudio-esound-compat pulseaudio-module-gconf pulseaudio-module-x11
> scim-bridge-gtk xdg-user-dirs-gtk yelp zenity
> Total size: 152 M
> After that completes, you can put "exec gnome-session" in ~/.xsession
> and restart X to land in a very normal looking F10 GNOME desktop.
> (I haven't tried to do much with it yet. Sound works, at least.)
> - Chris.
Now, the question I have is why we would chose GNOME over XFCE. I think
there are significant differences in system resource consumption.
I ask because the impression I had from informal tests was that a system
booting into GNOME was consuming about 3x as much RAM on boot (read via
ps_mem.py). My impression was that the benefit was not eaten up the
moment the I started running GTK applications; it seemed that under XFCE
I could open a fair number more Firefox tabs without running into lockup
than under GNOME. I know these aren't great metrics so I'll run some
more rigorous tests after we have two systems side-by-side for
Even though XFCE is not a Fedora-supported desktop environment, it is
readily supported in other distributions. We could easily borrow the
polish that XUbuntu has applied to its distribution and get a system
equally usable as GNOME.
More information about the Devel