#11931 NORM 1-firmw: XO-1 errors with a USB hub connected on port N if slot N in hub has a device connected

[Zarro Boogs per Child]

#11931: XO-1 errors with a USB hub connected on port N if slot N in hub has a
device connected
---------------------------------+------------------------------------------
 Reporter:  Quozl                |                 Owner:  Quozl               
     Type:  defect               |                Status:  new                 
 Priority:  normal               |             Milestone:  1-firmware          
Component:  ofw - open firmware  |               Version:  Development firmware
 Keywords:                       |           Next_action:  diagnose            
 Verified:  0                    |   Deployment_affected:                      
Blockedby:                       |              Blocking:                      
---------------------------------+------------------------------------------
 '''Startup tests'''

 The hub and a device were attached to the laptop in various ways, then the
 laptop was started, and ESC pressed on startup sound.

 ''USB FLASH drive''

 ||Hub plugged into||Device plugged into||Result||
 ||Port 1||Hub port 1||General Protection Exception||
 ||Port 1||Hub port 2||ok||
 ||Port 1||Hub port 3||ok||
 ||Port 1||Hub port 4||ok||
 ||Port 2||Hub port 1||ok||
 ||Port 2||Hub port 2||General Protection Exception||
 ||Port 2||Hub port 3||ok||
 ||Port 2||Hub port 4||ok||
 ||Port 3||Hub port 1||ok||
 ||Port 3||Hub port 2||ok||
 ||Port 3||Hub port 3||General Protection Exception||
 ||Port 3||Hub port 4||ok||

 ''USB Keyboard or Mouse''

 ||Hub plugged into||Device plugged into||Result||
 ||Port 1||Hub port 1||Error pattern 1||
 ||Port 1||Hub port 2||ok||
 ||Port 1||Hub port 3||ok||
 ||Port 1||Hub port 4||ok||
 ||Port 2||Hub port 1||ok||
 ||Port 2||Hub port 2||Error pattern 2||
 ||Port 2||Hub port 3||ok||
 ||Port 2||Hub port 4||ok||

 ''Error pattern 1''

 {{{
 Failed to set device address: 3
 Retrying with a delay
 Failed to set device address: 3
 Failed to get port status for port 2
 Failed to get port status for port 3
 Failed to get port status for port 4
 USB2 devices:
 /pci/usb at f,5/hub at 1,0
 /pci/usb at f,5/wlan at 0,0
 }}}

 ''Error pattern 2''

 {{{
 Failed to set device address: 3
 Retrying with a delay
 Failed to set device address: 3
 Failed to get port status for port 3
 Failed to get port status for port 4
 USB2 devices:
 /pci/usb at f,5/hub at 2,0
 /pci/usb at f,5/wlan at 0,0
 }}}

 '''Insertion tests'''

 The laptop was started without any devices attached to the USB ports.
 Then the hub with a USB FLASH drive was attached.  The USB FLASH drive was
 in the same hub port number as the host port.

 {{{
 ok p2
 Unimplemented package interface procedure
 Failed to probe hub port ff8ec89c
 Failed to get port status for port 3
 Failed to get port status for port 4
 Failed to probe hub port 1a0
 Failed to get port status for port 3
 Failed to get port status for port 4
 Failed to probe hub port ff8f4a78
 Failed to get port status for port 3
 Failed to get port status for port 4
 Failed to probe hub port ff82d0a8
 Failed to get port status for port 3
 Failed to get port status for port 4
 Failed to probe hub port ff82d188
 Failed to get port status for port 3
 Failed to get port status for port 4
 Failed to make root hub node for port -4917712
 USB2 devices:
 /pci/usb at f,5/hub at 2,0
 /pci/usb at f,5/wlan at 0,0
 /pci/usb at f,5/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0
 /pci/usb at f,5/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0
 /pci/usb at f,5/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0
 /pci/usb at f,5/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0
 /pci/usb at f,5/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0/hub at 2,0
 USB1 devices:
 }}}

-- 
Ticket URL: <http://dev.laptop.org/ticket/11931>
One Laptop Per Child <http://laptop.org/>
OLPC bug tracking system